Commie release while semi ok but not perfect, notable differences here are:
Commie is AAC, this has lossless audio
Commie did not filter out the in some cases fairly severe aliasing on the source.
Commie encode is bitrate starved causing noise and loss of detail.
Commie did not filter out the haloing on the source.
As far as if you should crop or not is a tossup, on one hand it does feature some misalignment/sharpening artifacts on those 2 pixels but on the other hand its ok in the majority of the scenes, i chose to leave it as is but its a toss either way, the problem Here us that commie didnt fill it with black borders causing resizing on playback on the majority of displays out there.
Video: 10bit x264 1920x1080 CRF16
Audio: Flac 5.1
Script: Commie
Commie - DeenPolice
Screen 1: Shows loss of detail and compression artifacts.
Screen 2: Shows the haloing and aliasing in addition to compression artifacts.
Screen 3: Shows how commie would look resized using a common resizing method.
Comments - 0